The marvelous Melanie Fishbane and I are back. And so are you! Great! Let’s get this party started! But first: If you’re brand-new to the blog, you may wish to know that this is part 2 of the interview. You can jump over to part 1 here and get acquainted with Melanie’s work in progress. (Or, if you’re like Kay Thompson’s irrepressible character, Eloise, you can skibble over to part 1.)
El Space: Aside from your work in progress, you’re working on some academic papers. Please tell us about those and how you came to write them.
Melanie: I love breaking things down and analyzing them, because it is a way for me to have a conversation with myself about what I’m thinking. Essays (and answering questions for a blog post) are a great way to do that!
I returned to essay writing in 2008, when I was inspired by the way teens were responding to Edward Cullen (Twilight), Darcy (Pride and Prejudice), and Gilbert Blythe (Anne of Green Gables) online. I considered how there was a similarity in the way that these characters were constructed that made teens fall in love with them and then wondered about my own literary loves—Gilbert Blythe and Almanzo Wilder in case you were interested.
Almanzo Wilder
Gilbert Blythe
El Space: I am! Mainly because I’m nosy.
Melanie: Well, in that case, you should check out this blog post where I talk about it.
El Space: Read it! Great post.
Melanie: I’ve been working on the Perfect Man Archetype for about four years now (it was my critical thesis) and hope to put my literary findings into a book one day.
El Space: I’d love to read that! And I could say something about finding the Perfect Man in general, but let’s move on!
Melanie: YA is having such an interesting growth and I think by tapping into this archetype, I’ve been able to connect to our literary heritage.
The other essay I’m working on is how L. M. Montgomery used writing to help her deal with loss, specifically what I see as her grief narratives: Rilla of Ingleside and The Blythes Are Quoted. I came to this, because I wanted to explore how Montgomery wrote about grieving and the process of grieving.
El Space: How do both worlds—your academic subjects and your novel—meet?
Melanie: Well, for the Perfect Man Archetype I’ve been able to look at how I construct the love interests in my novels and how I might subvert them. I want to create characters that I hope my readers will fall in love with, but will also, hopefully, surprise them.
For the Montgomery essay on grieving, I came to this because my novel is also a grief narrative, as my protagonist is recovering from the sudden death of her father and I hoped to gain insight into how to write this with authenticity.
El Space: If you were to write an academic paper on a current heroine, not including your own, who would you choose? Why?
Melanie: Good question! You know, I don’t know. The first character that came to mind was Katniss from The Hunger Games, mostly because she has inspired a stream of strong willed, hurt, emotionally detached characters in YA. I wonder if maybe it is because I remember being so emotional as a teen but don’t think that I even understood what was going on or why I felt the way that I did. In a way, that is being disconnected, going into the head, not the heart. Come to think of it, my novel deals with this a bit, too.
El Space: What advice would you give to a teen about writing?
Melanie: Write things that inspire you and don’t worry about being bad. You will be, but that is okay. I would also suggest keeping a journal, because it will allow you to safely work with your own story and emotions. Then if you see a writing workshop at your local library, take it. And don’t take the feedback too personally; you aren’t a bad person or a bad writer if the sentence is bad; it is just that the sentence is bad and that can be fixed. I wish someone had told me that as a teenager. I might not have waited ten years to go back to writing fiction and poetry.
Wow! Thanks, Melanie, for being such a great guest. (She also picks up after herself and doesn’t leave coffee mug rings on the table. Nice.)
And thank you for stopping by. If you have questions for Melanie, you know what to do! Please comment below!
Eloise illustration by Hilary Knight found at truetostyle.com. Gilbert Blythe photo from sjaejones.com. Almanzo Wilder photo from Wikipedia. Rilla of Ingleside cover from lmmresearchgroup.org. Other book covers from Goodreads.com. Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss photo found at graphic-engine.swarthmore.edu.
Very nice interview and wonderful advice from Melanie about keeping a journal and not feeling like you are a bad person/writer because of one mistake or sentence. Thanks for sharing!
Thanks for stopping by. I’ve been thinking of you. How is your pain level today?
That is so very sweet of you!!! The drugs are working so the pain level is much better! Thanks for asking! 🙂
I’m glad to hear that. I’m sure it’s not easy.
I’m glad what I said was helpful.
L. Marie — thank you so much for bringing Melanie to us all the way from Canada! She’s one of my favorite VCFA people 🙂
Melanie — I can’t wait to read your WIP! It sounds like it has elements from your first workshop piece, which (as you know) I LOVED! Thank you for a wonderful interview. Good luck with the writing.
Thanks, Laura! You are one of my favourite people, too. I look forward to seeing what you think about my WIP. Good luck with your writing, too.
We’re all excited about it!
I like reading about the different processes writers go through. There are common threads to many, but each have their own little “deviances.”
True. And it’s great for me to remember that. I sometimes try to impose my process on others sadly. But everyone is different. Thanks for stopping by!
Interestingly enough, I’ve never read hunger games!
I recommend reading at least the first book.
But something about a girl fighting like a gladiator deters me every time…
Ah, yes. I understand.
You do? That surprises me…
I like to surprise people at least once!
Yes, but thrice is better!
Now, now. Don’t get greedy.
😆
Great advice for young writers–or anyone just starting out! And sorry about those coffee rings on your table, Linda.
It’s all right, Lyn. You signed my copy of Rogue so all is forgiven. 😉
Thanks to both of you. I loved reading about Melanie’s various projects. Both the essays and the fiction sound wonderful!
You’re quite welcome. Yes, her projects are great. I recommend her blog post on the Perfect Man also.
Thanks, L. Marie! I appreciate the shout out.
I’m trying to catch up on all of the “Writer’s Process” posts that I missed. So far it’s been enjoyable. I still love your interview style and presentation. 🙂 I learn something new with each one of your posts. Plus, I find the exchanges you present us to be fascinating as well as ‘educational’ (for us writers). 😉
I’m behind on things too, Will. Thanks for reading the interview posts. They’re always fun to do.